You said you'd never lie

But you did it anyway

So how am I supposed to feel

When you said, "It's so real, " to my face?

And you said you'd make a promise

But a promise never stays

So how am I supposed to act

When it's just how it is nowadays?

And I swear

We kinda fell in love with the pain

And I'm scared

We don't even know the right way

I wish I loved you in the '90s

'Cause I know that we would work

Say wrong place, wrong time, should've been alive

Bet it wouldn't hurt

If I had loved you in the '90s

Back when life wasn't a blur

Say right guy, right vibe, wouldn't have to try

Bet it wouldn't hurt

If I had loved you in the '90s

If I had loved you in the '90s

What happened to the guy

Picking up the girl?

And now you speed down the highway

And don't care to say a word

In my head, it's kinda dreamy

I imagine it with you

On the lawn, record on

Looking at the sky like '92, oh

And I swear

We kinda fell in love with the pain

And I'm scared

We don't even know the right way

I wish I loved you in the '90s

'Cause I know that we would work

Say wrong place, wrong time, should've been alive

Bet it wouldn't hurt

If I had loved you in the '90s

Back when life wasn't a blur

Say right guy, right vibe, wouldn't have to try

Bet it wouldn't hurt

If I had loved you in the '90s

If I had loved you in the '90s

Wish I loved you in the '90s

'Cause I know that we would work

Say wrong place, wrong time

Bet it wouldn't hurt